Tag: #immigration_executive_order

Hope Ninth Circuit Decision

Analysis of the Ninth Circuit’s Decision on Travel Ban

Well, to start with, judges are people. If you attack them, they subconsciously, will hold it against you. So please have some respect for other branches of government Mr. President.

What Happens Now?

So the three judges panel upheld the lower court’s ruling banning the ban. The court ruled that the Plaintiffs have an interest in allowing travelers in. The court balanced the national security interest and the potential harm to the Paintiffs and ruled that the harm outweighs the national security interest.

What Happens Now?

The Administration now has two options: ask for a full review by the Ninth Circuit or appeal to the Supreme Court. The two options are very tricky. The first one might be the better option however, since we still have eight justices on the higher court. The 4-4 decision threat might lead to a delay on the administration’s behalf until their nominee is confirmed.

What should the Administration do?

I believe that the best course of action is for the Administration to withdraw the order. I doubt that’ll ever happen, however. I think the the President’s statement during the campaign and the fact that the order discriminates against Muslim refugees taint the order and make it unconstitutional.

I don’t think that the battle over this is over by any means. The President just sent out a  tweet saying “See You in Court”. To read the decision, click here.

Phillippines location

Democracy WINS! Judge Suspends Immigration Executive Order Nationwide

GREAT News!! Last night, a federal judge ordered the immediate suspension of enforcement of the President Trump’s executive order on refugees and immigration. The order is nation wide and is effective immediately.
A not of caution however, the ban is temporary and has to be turned into a permanent ban after a merits hearing. The interesting this however, is the fact that the judge believed the arguments from the suing states that President Trump’s statements during the campaign show that the ban was in fact a “Muslim Ban”. I have been arguing this point since the order was issued and I knew that a competent judge will issue such ruling.
I have read reports that DHS and DOS have suspended enforcement of all things related to this order. This means that people who were turned away will be allowed to board plans to the US. Also, DOS will be reissuing cancelled visas. Lastly, all halt in adjudications from DHS and USCIS will be lifted.
I hope that this temporary restraining order will become permanent. However, the administration has already signaled that the order will be appealed. I will stay in touch to update you.